时间:2025-10-08 04:04:42 来源:网络整理编辑:時尚
Uber Technologies Inc. is offering its drivers an average of about a dollar apiece to dispose of all
Uber Technologies Inc. is offering its drivers an average of about a dollar apiece to dispose of alleged labor code violations that their own lawyer said might be worth billions.
The ride-hailing company asked a state judge in Los Angeles Wednesday to approve a $7.75 million settlement to resolve claims stemming from the company’s refusal to give California drivers the protections and benefits of employees. The accord doesn’t require Uber to stop classifying the drivers as independent contractors.
The claims by Steven Price, who sought to represent as many as 1.6 million California drivers in a class action, were brought under the state’s Private Attorneys General Act, or PAGA, which gives employees the right to step into the shoes of the state labor secretary to bring enforcement actions. Under the 2004 law, the state keeps 75 percent of any penalties won. Attorneys for employers have nicknamed it the “bounty hunter” and “sue your boss” law because of the remaining 25 percent is a reward for the workers who bring the case. Thousands of such lawsuits have been filed in the past 12 years.
SEE ALSO:Getting married is more expensive than everThe Price case poses a special threat to Uber. The company in September won an appeals court ruling that potentially eviscerated a more advanced class action in San Francisco federal court by forcing the vast majority of 385,000 California and Massachusetts drivers in the case to proceed through arbitration one at a time. But PAGA claims, like those filed by Price in state court, can’t be shunted into arbitration.
Christopher Morosoff, a lawyer representing Price, said at a June hearing in San Francisco that his case cited 17 labor code violations, compared with just two claims -- tips and mileage -- in the federal case for which the PAGA penalties were estimated at $1 billion by the state agency that oversees labor code enforcement.
"Do the math there," he told U.S. District Judge Edward Chen at the time. "The numbers may be staggering, and they may be in the billions, and you may not want to look at them, but they are real."
In Wednesday’s filing, Morosoff and attorneys for Uber urged the Los Angeles judge to approve the accord, calling it a “reasonable and fair compromise” and “the largest PAGA settlement ever, exceeding all other known PAGA settlements by millions of dollars.”
“This settlement appropriately balances the objective of the PAGA statute and the risks of litigation posed to each side, while avoiding an unjust result,” they wrote.
The agreement calls for about $1.7 million to paid to drivers and earmarks about $2.9 million in PAGA penalties for California’s Labor and Workforce Development Agency, with the rest of the settlement sum going toward attorney fees and administration costs. The amount each driver gets depends on how many weeks they have actively driven for Uber.
An Uber spokeswoman said the company is pleased with the settlement and looks forward to resolving other cases. Morosoff didn’t immediately respond to a call seeking comment.
SEE ALSO:Companies anticipate big software deals, with help from TrumpUber said in a court filing that the Price settlement would resolve PAGA claims of drivers who used its app from July 8, 2013, until the date a Los Angles judge signs off on the deal.
Court approval of the accord isn’t a sure thing. In the San Francisco case, which would have resolved claims for tips and mileage valued by the drivers’ lawyer at $852 million, Chen rejected a $100 million settlement in August. He said the $1 million allotted to resolve PAGA claims was inadequate in light of those claims being valued at as much as $1 billion.
Shannon Liss-Riordan, the lawyer representing drivers in the San Francisco case, was criticized by Morosoff, who said she folded too easily to Uber in her settlement on minimum wage and overtime claims, which the deal valued at zero.
Liss-Riordan, complaining that she was left in the dark about the Price settlement until it was first announced in November, tried unsuccessfully to get Chen to try to wrestle the PAGA claims away from the Los Angeles case so she could pursue them in San Francisco. Chen said in an order that he was reluctant to interfere "with a state court’s resolution of what is, after all, a state law issue."
Charlotte Garden, a Seattle University associate law professor who has followed the Uber litigation, called the settlement a “bargain” for Uber, saying it appears to be proportionally smaller than the sum than Chen signaled that he would have approved in the San Francisco case.
SEE ALSO:Why the feds are losing the war on fake Super Bowl merchandiseThe professor also said that if the Price settlement is approved, it will advance the company’s “divide and conquer” approach to driver lawsuits.
It may reduce the threat of the San Francisco lawsuit to the “nuisance value” of fighting potentially thousands of individual drivers in arbitration, she said. While that cost could still be considerable because Uber has committed to covering the expenses of arbitration, “it will almost certainly be less than a case with a viable path towards litigating all the drivers’ claims on an aggregate basis,” Garden said.
The Los Angeles case is Price v. Uber Technologies Inc., BC554512, California Superior Court, Los Angeles County (Los Angeles). The San Francisco case is O’Connor v. Uber Technologies Inc., 13-cv-03826, U.S. District Court, Northern District of California (San Francisco).
TopicsUber
Xiaomi accused of copying again, this time by Jawbone2025-10-08 03:40
踢球者:拜仁續約格納布裏不順 多家豪門虎視眈眈2025-10-08 03:20
中國女足:王霜的傷勢疑似為骨裂 正在積極恢複中2025-10-08 03:19
草蜢隊官方 :賈博琰將租借加盟克羅地亞乙級聯賽杜布拉瓦隊2025-10-08 03:03
There's a big piece of fake chicken stuck to this phone case2025-10-08 02:52
鬧崩了 !C羅不認可朗尼克能力 朗帥忍不了CR7低迷2025-10-08 02:49
皇馬全場尷尬0射正 !三年內第一遭 上次也是戰巴黎2025-10-08 02:18
火爆依舊 !佩佩腳踢對手高層 恐禁賽兩個月至兩年2025-10-08 02:02
Give your kitchen sponge a rest on this adorable bed2025-10-08 01:59
93分14秒 !姆巴佩瘋狂1過2絕殺皇馬 先打爆再加盟?2025-10-08 01:28
Tourist survives for month in frozen New Zealand wilderness after partner dies2025-10-08 03:55
十年 !國米再戰歐冠淘汰賽 主場惜敗紅軍亦可昂首2025-10-08 03:49
波叔 :梅西戰皇馬會做重要貢獻 巴黎等歐冠50年了2025-10-08 03:28
瓜帥盼續約費爾南迪尼奧1年 願提供球員+教練角色2025-10-08 03:18
Visualizing July's astounding global temperature records2025-10-08 03:00
安切洛蒂 :皇馬依然有機會逆轉 姆巴佩是歐洲最佳2025-10-08 02:42
93分14秒!姆巴佩瘋狂1過2絕殺皇馬 先打爆再加盟?2025-10-08 02:13
曼聯更衣室又要炸 ? C羅鬧小團隊惹怒眾英格蘭國腳2025-10-08 02:05
Singapore rolls out video2025-10-08 01:44
著急!補時階段對手詐傷 誇雷斯馬公主抱送他出場2025-10-08 01:26