时间:2026-11-20 04:16:31 来源:网络整理编辑:焦點
If the past few years have taught us anything, it's that algorithms should not be blindly trusted.Th
If the past few years have taught us anything, it's that algorithms should not be blindly trusted.
The latest math-induced headache comes from Australia, where an automated compliance system appears to be issuing incorrect notices to some of Australia's most vulnerable people, asking them to prove they were entitled to past welfare benefits.
Politicians and community advocates have called foul on the system, rolled out by Australia's social services provider, Centrelink.
SEE ALSO:Facebook reveals how many times governments requested data in 2016Launched in July, the system was intended to streamline the detection of overpayments made to welfare recipients and automatically issue notices of any discrepancies.

The media and Reddit threads have since been inundated with complaints from people who say they are being accused of being "welfare cheats" without cause, thanks to faulty data.
The trouble lies with the algorithm's apparent difficulty accurately matching tax office data with Centrelink records, according to the Guardian, although department spokesperson Hank Jongen told Mashableit remains "confident" in the system.
"People have 21 days from the date of their letter to go online and update their information," he said. "The department is determined to ensure that people get what they are entitled to, nothing more, nothing less."
Independent politician Andrew Wilkie accused the "heavy-handed" system of terrifying the community.
The siren call of big data has proved irresistible to governments globally, provoking a rush to automate and digitise.
"My office is still being inundated with calls and emails from all around the country telling stories of how people have been deemed guilty until proven innocent and sent to the debt collectors immediately," he said in a statement in early December.
The situation is upsetting albeit unsurprising. The siren call of big data has proved irresistible to governments globally, provoking a rush to automate and digitise.
What these politicians seem to like, above all, is that such algorithms promise speed and less man hours.
Alan Tudge, the minister for human services, proudly announcedthat Centrelink's system was issuing 20,000 "compliance interventions" a week in December, up from a previous 20,000 per year when the process was manual. Such a jump seems incredible, and perhaps dangerous.
As data scientist Cathy O'Neil lays out in her recent book Weapons of Math Destruction, the judgments made by algorithms governing everything from our credit scores to our pension payments can easily be wrong -- they were created by humans, after all.
The math-powered applications powering the data economy were based on choices made by fallible human beings. Some of these choices were no doubt made with the best intentions. Nevertheless, many of these models encoded human prejudice, misunderstanding and bias into the software systems that increasingly managed our lives. Like gods, these mathematical models were opaque, their working invisible to all but the highest priests in their domain: mathematicians and computer scientists.
These murky systems can inflict the greatest punishment on the most vulnerable.
Take, for example, a ProPublicareport that found an algorithm being used in American criminal sentencing to predict the accused's likelihood of committing a future crime was biased against black people. The corporation that produced the program, Northpointe, disputed the finding.
O'Neil also details in her book how predictive policing software can create "a pernicious feedback loop" in low income neighbourhoods. These computer programs may recommend areas be patrolled to counter low impact crimes like vagrancy, generating more arrests, and so creating the data that gets those neighbourhoods patrolled still more.
Even Google doesn't get it right. Troublingly, in 2015, a web developer spotted the company's algorithms automatically tagging two black people as "gorillas."
Former Kickstarter data scientist Fred Benenson has come up with a good term for this rose-coloured glasses view of what numbers can do: "Mathwashing."
"Mathwashing can be thought of using math terms (algorithm, model, etc.) to paper over a more subjective reality," he told Technical.lyin an interview. As he goes on to to describe, we often believe computer programs are able to achieve an objective truth out of reach for us humans -- we are wrong.
"Algorithm and data driven products will always reflect the design choices of the humans who built them, and it's irresponsible to assume otherwise," he said.
The point is, algorithms are only as good as we are. And we're not that good.
The Weeknd teases new music in Instagram post2026-11-20 04:14
網友偶遇王大治攜妻女晉香祈福 一家三口溫馨十足2026-11-20 04:11
“溫莎當下·麥克成風”大賽46位選手引爆工人體育場!2026-11-20 04:04
一場耳畔和舌尖的遠行2026-11-20 03:53
Olympian celebrates by ordering an intimidating amount of McDonald's2026-11-20 03:06
“世界地球日”張昕宇 、梁紅夫婦走進上海交大講述地球之極的故事2026-11-20 02:40
2018CES Asia2026-11-20 02:40
SNH48 COS火影忍者 ,軟萌小姐姐秒變酷帥忍者 !2026-11-20 02:24
U.S. government issues warning on McDonald's recalled wearable devices2026-11-20 02:17
樂多港街頭塗鴉文化節正式開啟2026-11-20 02:10
Fake news reports from the Newseum are infinitely better than actual news2026-11-20 03:51
恒信文化亮相上海國際電影節 構建多元影視生態圈2026-11-20 03:50
梁田:主持人的光芒 遮不住隱藏的演技2026-11-20 03:11
老友相聚萬眾狂歡!心係天下攜周華健引爆泉城2026-11-20 02:59
Tyler, the Creator helped Frank Ocean celebrate 'Blonde' release in a delicious way2026-11-20 02:54
一鳴“金”人,神秘大咖將亮相熊貓“酷”係列AI音響電視發布會2026-11-20 02:25
朱丹朱亞文520空降上海 動情告白 ,隻為向母乳致敬2026-11-20 02:17
深圳動漫節 紅牛攜手迅雷直播帶你一探真相2026-11-20 02:14
We asked linguists if Donald Trump speaks like that on purpose2026-11-20 02:07
《溫暖的弦》張嘉倪將秀場搬上熒幕,現代劇回歸之作令人期待2026-11-20 01:56