时间:2025-09-16 21:47:28 来源:网络整理编辑:探索
Will the realconclusive study on the health effects of sedentary behavior PLEASE stand up??? Or sit
Will the realconclusive study on the health effects of sedentary behavior PLEASE stand up??? Or sit down ... who even knows anymore.
See, it's like this -- every so often a new study comes out declaring that sitting for hours on end is essentially your ticket to an early grave. So then you read it, become increasingly terrified and make a conscious decision to stand more often.
SEE ALSO:Netflix cheating is a phenomenon that can put a pause on your relationshipBut just when you finallyget your standing desk approved by your office manager, another study declares that standing for prolonged periods is equally as threatening to your health.
So where does that leave us, scientists? Alternating between chairs and standing desks? Taking bathroom breaks every five minutes to ensure we get our 10,000 steps in? Jiggling our legs at earthquake-inducing speeds to get that blood circulating? We're just trying to stay alive, here.
Although standing desks are all the rage now, back in 2002, standing was NOT consideredsmart. A study discovered some serious health risks associated with standing for more than 8 hours, ranging from lower back pain, foot aches, preterm birth and even spontaneous abortions. In 2005, prolonged standing at work was also linked to an excess risk of varicose veins. Yikes.
There's also this terrifying July 2014 study abouthealth risks associated with prolonged standing at work that will make you feel better each time you drop to your seat. In good news for all the sitters out there, a 2015 study by theInternational Journal of Epidemiologyconcluded that sitting time isn't linked to a risk of death (or as they put it, "all-cause mortality"). Phew. Instead, a lack of physical activity is the problem.
Via GiphyThe latest study to join the confusing pile comes from a team of Australian and British scientists, who found that -- despite all the fretting by daily cubicle inhabitants across the globe -- sitting might not be so bad after all, at least when it comes to diabetes.
In a January paper, published in the British Journal of Sports Medicine, the researchers said there was little evidence linking sitting with incident diabetes over 13 years. The study involved about 4,800 British civil servants, who were on average 44 years old and didn't have diabetes or heart or circulatory problems at the beginning.
Emmanuel Stamatakis, lead author of the paper and an associate professor at the University of Sydney, suggested that we think about sitting at work not so much as a health risk, but as a reflection of our sedentary lifestyles. "Rather than being the 'new smoking,' we need to think of sitting as an important part of the wider problem of physical inactivity," he wrote Tuesday on The Conversation.
So by all means, sit down at work, but at least hit the gym and do some cardio later on.
The craze around standing desks started slowly. Two studies in 2010, linked sedentary behavior to an increased risk of depressionand cancer. Then in 2012, a Diabetologiastudyfound an abnormal amount of sitting also makes you more susceptible to diabetes, cardiovascular disease and death.
In August 2014, Dr. James Levine -- aka inventor of the treadmill desk -- declaredsitting to be "more dangerous than smoking," a claim which set the world (or at least the break room) on fire. If you weren't freaking out enough and doing squats at your desk, another studythen hit the shelves in 2016, stating that sitting for prolonged stretches might boost your risk of Type 2 diabetes, even if you exercise. Yep.
Via GiphyBut what about my really expensive standing desk? Should I throw it in the bin?
To put things in perspective: Last year, researchers looked at a bunch of studies on the supposed health benefits of standing desks. They found that many individual studies were poorly designed, showed evidence of bias or had too few participants, according to the systematic Cochrane Review.
Their conclusion: there's little proof that buying a standing desk actually means you sit less. In good news, at least it appears like you are doing something healthy.
Since at least the early 2000s, a steady stream of reports have warned of potential health consequences for people who both sit for too long AND stand for too long on the job. So what are we supposed to think? We're tired, can we please take a seat?
Media outlets (ourselves included) are partly to blame for casting these studies as definitive, all-encompassing verdicts on whether you should or shouldn't free your rear end from the chair. But individual studies alone can't tell us the whole picture, said Kay Dickersin, a professor of epidemiology at the Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health in Baltimore, Maryland.
"You want to look at all the evidence. You don't want to just look at one study at a time," she said.
"You want to look at all the evidence"
Often researchers focus only on a specific group of people: for instance, workers who stand on their feet all day (say nurses or factory workers), and not office workers who choose to use a standing desk. Or, scientists may look at particular outcomes -- diabetes, obesity, heart disease -- and not the overall health benefits or risks.
Our unscientific takeaway? Mixing it up at work is better than only sitting, or only standing, for the whole day. Or, if you want to get specific, Cornell University experts advise that after sitting for 20-30 minutes, stand up for a bit and move around.
So there you have it: science can't help you, and neither can we.
TopicsHealth
Pokémon Go is so big that it has its own VR porn parody now2025-09-16 21:36
滬媒:女足奧運聯隊不是不想接受采訪 而是被下了封口令2025-09-16 21:24
18日賠率:利物浦曼城主場均告捷 阿森納需防平2025-09-16 20:49
米蘭殘陣無懼尤文 9年來首次戰斑馬連場聯賽不敗2025-09-16 20:39
The five guys who climbed Australia's highest mountain, in swimwear2025-09-16 20:32
滬媒:女足奧運聯隊不是不想接受采訪 而是被下了封口令2025-09-16 20:16
梅西鬱悶!任意球中柱+單刀被撲 平局時早早被換下2025-09-16 20:06
哀悼!熱刺傳奇射手吉米2025-09-16 20:03
Pokémon Go is so big that it has its own VR porn parody now2025-09-16 19:35
比賽日 :瓦爾迪破門難救主萊斯特12025-09-16 19:02
Sound the alarms: Simone Biles finally met Zac Efron2025-09-16 21:34
傅明將繼續執法12強賽第三輪 馬寧轉場亞冠淘汰賽2025-09-16 20:44
國足封閉苦練需防心理疲勞 10月兩場裁判讓人憂慮2025-09-16 20:39
多點開花!弟媳破僵1數據僅次德羅巴 坎特神勇歸來2025-09-16 20:35
Samsung Galaxy Note7 teardown reveals the magic behind the phone's iris scanner2025-09-16 20:22
酸了 !富安健洋對抗成功率100% 79次觸球全場最多2025-09-16 19:44
武磊替補出戰29分鍾僅4次觸球 西媒:他貢獻很少2025-09-16 19:34
魯媒:中國足球太需要能為失敗哭泣的人 不少人已被異化2025-09-16 19:34
Samsung Galaxy Note7 teardown reveals the magic behind the phone's iris scanner2025-09-16 19:23
比賽日:瓦爾迪破門難救主萊斯特12025-09-16 19:07