时间:2025-10-08 00:02:53 来源:网络整理编辑:時尚
Another day, another Congressional hearing on big tech...right? Not so fast. Tuesday’s hearing
Another day, another Congressional hearing on big tech...right?
Not so fast. Tuesday’s hearing, which once again saw Facebook’s Mark Zuckerberg and Twitter’s Jack Dorsey remotely take the hot seat, was a little bit different.
What made this one unique? This hearing was the first time Congress got to grill Zuckerberg and Dorsey since the election.
Republican lawmakers calledfor the Senate Judiciary Committee hearing, titled “Censorship, Suppression, and the 2020 Election,” as a result of actionstaken by the social media platforms against a New York Poststory concerning leaks from Joe Biden’s son’s laptop.
When the story was first published in October, Facebook “reduced the article’s distribution” in order to give it time to be fact-checked. Regardless, the link to the New York Poststory was still widely shared on the social networking site.
Twitter, however, blocked the link outright and even suspended the Post’s Twitter account. The company later reversedthese decisions and changed its rules surrounding leaked material, sayingthat its policies were wrong in this scenario. (It should be noted that many New York Post staffers distancedthemselves from the Hunter Biden laptop story after it was published.)
Tuesday’s hearing did mostly go down in typical fashion, with Republicans blasting the two CEOs for anti-conservative bias, a claim that’s been pretty much disproven in a studyperformed by a former Republican senator.
All in all, most of the hearing went as follows about the main topic, content moderation: Democrats want Facebook and Twitter to do more to block misinformation and extremist speech. Republicans want Facebook and Twitter to stop blocking their misinformation and extremist speech.
Unfortunately for the American people, both parties, as proven by the opening exchange between committee chairman Sen. Lindsey Graham and Sen. Richard Blumenthal, think the best way to accomplish what they want is to revoke Section 230.
Section 230of the Communications Decency Act of 1996 is basically the law that keeps “free speech” flowing on the internet. It shields platforms from legal liability for content posted by their users. Without Section 230, tech platforms would be forced to be much more restrictive in terms of what type of content they allow to be posted. It would also mean that smaller companies, or even the average blogger, could be held liable for comments made by people posting on their sites.
“Section 230 has to be changed because we can’t get there from here without change,” said Graham.
“Change is going to come,” followed Blumenthal in his remarks. “No question. And I plan to bring aggressive reform to 230.”
Both Zuckerberg and Dorsey conceded that they’d like to see some revisions to Section 230.
However, there were a few other interesting moments.
One particularly fascinating exchange was when Sen. Amy Klobuchar asked Jack Dorsey about Facebook’s decision to undermine Twitter’s now-defunct video platform, Vine...with Zuckerberg right there in the same video chat.
In 2018, leaked public documents showed that Zuckerberg personally requestedthat Facebook cut off Vine’s ability to connect the app’s users with their Facebook friends. Dorsey described the turn of events as very "challenging” but unfortunately avoided going much further.
Senator Blumenthal pressed Zuckerberg to “commit” to banning President Trump’s former campaign manager and chief strategist, Stephen Bannon, from its platform. In the days following the election, Bannon called for the beheading of FBI Director Chris Wray and Dr. Anthony Fauci in a video syndicated across his social media accounts.
"Senator, no,” answered Zuckerberg. “That's not what our policies would suggest that we should do in this case.”
Facebook did remove the video, but Zuckerberg insisted that Bannon had not violated enough of the platform’s policies to constitute a ban. In contrast, Twitter bannedBannon from its platform following his video post.
The Facebook founder and CEO also denied accusations that the company has removed strikes against conservative pages for breaking platform rules and exempted them from certain misinformation policies.
Zuckerberg’s claims are contradicted by multiple reports over the past few months. Internal leaks from the company show that rules were relaxedfor conservative pages and misinformation labels were changedin order to avoid claims of anti-conservative bias. Facebook even reportedly firedan employee who was collecting this evidence to criticize the special treatment given to right-wing Facebook pages.
Speaking of Facebook’s employees, at the hearing, Zuckerberg classified his employees as more “left” than the platform’s user base. Claims like this add credence to the right’s beliefs that Facebook has an anti-conservative bias. However, it’s never mentioned that the people with actual power in the company, namely executives such as its VP of Global Public Policy Joel Kaplan, are not only deeply conservative...they’ve literally worked in Republican administrations.
Twitter CEO Jack Dorsey took most of the heat from Republican senators, like Ted Cruz, mainly due to the platform’s misinformation policies. Sen. Masha Blackburn grilled Twitter for its prior business relationships with China-based companies like Huaweiand Alibaba. While the Huawei criticism and anti-Chinese government talking points from Republicans are not new, it seems like the Alibaba rhetoric is a recent addition.
But perhaps the oddest moment of the day was when Lindsey Graham excused himself, forcing the proceedings to take a break just a little over an hour into the hearing.
Just moments after leaving the hearing, Senator Graham was seen talkingto reporters, taking part in the charade of attempting to overturn the election results in Trump’s favor.
TopicsFacebookSocial MediaTwitter
Olympic security asks female Iranian fan to drop protest sign2025-10-07 23:53
記者:武磊落選是考慮到留洋堅守不易 國家隊誰也沒說放棄他2025-10-07 23:51
滬媒發文點評“馮鞏大戰” :嘴上功夫救不了中國足球2025-10-07 23:45
C羅領銜朗尼克欽點曼聯6大引擎 另5個?可太糟糕了2025-10-07 23:20
Australian football makes history with first LGBT Pride Game2025-10-07 23:00
韓國12強賽大名單 :孫興慜領銜 孫準浩無緣2025-10-07 22:43
梅西父親幾天前聯係了巴薩 未來幾周將有大量消息2025-10-07 22:21
周最佳 :本澤馬壓C羅榮膺MVP 萊萬哈弗茨進最佳陣2025-10-07 22:07
Singapore gets world's first driverless taxis2025-10-07 21:38
金英權:蔚山現代與廣州隊風格相同 現在作比較還為時過早2025-10-07 21:21
Carlos Beltran made a very interesting hair choice2025-10-07 23:39
韓媒 :韓國主場對陣伊朗 將售出超過6萬張球票2025-10-07 23:28
津媒:楊帆迅速融入津門虎 張衛等海港球員正在試訓2025-10-07 23:17
國足教練組非常滿意蔣光太備戰態度 已提前10天開始訓練2025-10-07 22:58
Plane makes emergency landing after engine rips apart during flight2025-10-07 22:28
津媒:楊帆迅速融入津門虎 張衛等海港球員正在試訓2025-10-07 22:27
全國女足錦標賽次輪打響 衛冕冠軍武漢女足兩連敗無緣8強2025-10-07 22:27
詹俊 :不理解瓜帥為何不換人 水晶宮韌性值得誇讚2025-10-07 22:20
Tourist survives for month in frozen New Zealand wilderness after partner dies2025-10-07 22:10
國足西征放棄征調武磊 枯坐板凳狀態很難有所保障2025-10-07 21:45